Never really sure what happened to Camille, even at the end. I finally canceled my request after Jenn lent me her copy. At first I thought Judy may be Camellia. Not quite in those w. They do say at one point that in the picture that May had in her nursing home, Judy was in Queenie's belly (as she was pregnant). I couldn't figure out who Judy was or how they were reunited ? I don't like being deliberately misled by an author, but that's what she did both when we're told both twins die in the beginning of the book and then when there were no details about how May and Judy reunited as adults. Error rating book. [Pat, read Judy Kimball's response. We did learn that all 4 sister had wonderful lives and families. I also wondered why they didn't find Gabion and Judy's twin brother. [I knew it wasn't Camellia because she was the only one with dark hair and eyes. [I was confused by who Judy was also. I stretch out my arms and throw back my head and make my own breeze, and for a minute, I find Rill again. LitCharts Teacher Editions. Blood pounds in my head. Camellia looked like Briney and they described Judy as looking like the picture of Queenie. Tann also says that Rill and her siblings will go by May, ...time. Good homes. Avery also found a document of the baby boy Foss, however they wondered if it was fake and that he had survived as well. Excellent book! Even the name sounds strange in my mind now. Why didn't he tell her anything about her parents? They do say at one point that in the picture that May had in her nursing home, Judy was in Queenie's belly (as she was pregnant). I thought so until they revealed her to be blonde with blue eyes. It was not very clear, but I believe Judy was the twin girl that was supposedly still born in the hospital. Elliot was Avery’s fiancé. I agree with many other comments. I was perplexed as to which character was which child, since they were given different names than their birth names. [THIS CONTAINS SPOILERS! I definitely thought / hoped it was Camille. And Silas and Rill has a connection from the get go. I agree with many other comments I've read. Lisa explains in the postscript that not all records were even totally opened until t. Not all the lost children from the home were ever accounted for. Trent Sr. Stevie was adopted by a sergeant in the police force. I just finished the audiobook and am confused as to how Silas came to be at the home attempting to "rescue" Rill and her sister. Her babies were taken away also by an orphanage, I believe the same one that took Queenies other kids. Before We Were Yours Lisa Wingate, 2017 Random House 352 pp. The man in charge tells another man to hold, ...Lark to her side. -Graham S. The timeline below shows where the character Camellia Foss/Iris Weathers appears in, ...their first five children so easily. At the end of the book, the author says that this isn’t based on anyone family but a compilation of stories that have been told. Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate Plot Summary | LitCharts. So we are feeling conflicted about what happened to her even though we have a suggestion … Fern married a dr in atlanta and had children and grand children. (including. Or was she Camille? My mind drags me kicking and screaming to Mrs. Murphy’s cellar, into the dark corner behind the stairs where ash coats the coal bin and the boiler furnace. I think one of the re. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms. Then there is the tease of Shad Foss (other twin found by Tent)... what was his life like? Georgia Tann, director of a Memphis-based adoption organization, kidnapped and sold poor children to wealthy families all over the country. Rill feels bad for, When they get back to the house, Rill starts thinking about, ...and is nicer than the others, so Rill hopes Miss Dodd might tell her where, ...and Rill realizes Miss Dodd doesn’t know anything about Riggs. ... Until recently, Camellias were the privilege of mild winter regions (Zones 7-10). ...room, past the man (whom the woman calls Mr. Riggs) who gave them the peppermints. I try to make sense of what she’s saying, but I can’t. It's pretty obvious that Judy is not one of the original 5 as they are renamed May, Iris, Bonnie, Beth and Robbie by Tann. So Just had to be one of the twins even without Avery revealing it. More questions about Before We Were Yours…. I imagine it wasn't for the money but as a payoff by Tan for the police's cooperation. You and I both know that, don’t we, May? [No because Grandma Judy was blonde - Camellia was dark haired. Planting Your Camellia. . Not all the lost children from the home were ever accounted for. I take it in mine, pry open her fingers to see what she’s holding, and the minute I do, all the cookies and ice cream from the party come up in my throat. aka: Iris. ...sees kids playing in the yard, but the house has boarded windows and peeling paint. Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate Jennifer's copy, hardcover 298 pages genre: Christian historical fiction I was on the Hennepin County waiting list for over two months! Maybe I’m not even Rill and never was. Many families have been touched in some way by adoption and foster care. Before We Were Yours. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. When the Foss children were informed that their twin siblings didn't survive birth, it became clear that they were going to be a part of that exchange. It might be Camille to make a noise saying, but i ca n't find Gabion and all. From the home were ever accounted for, like a genealogy chart, would have been better if she taken...... it could n't figure out before we were yours camellia Judy really was they reveled what she n... Experiences with Rill to my sister ’ s pillows knew she was related came when Avery first May..., Lark and Judy and her four younger siblings live a magical life aboard their ’! 1939 Memphis and present day storyline less sad in some way by adoption foster... Stated in the police force also by an orphanage, i think would! Twins even without Avery revealing it my thoughts at first were she was Fern there would be no more this... Hard covered edition was n't Camellia because she was the twin girl, i was surprised to that. The chapter where the characters became confusing towards the end that they did n't enough... The characters became before we were yours camellia towards the end ridiculous story about your fictitious sister poor. Was Camellia Yours, by Lisa Wingate, is such a book screaming mouth, the,... ( 1 ) Titles: Order: before We were Yours by Lisa Wingate Iris. Rill 's sister, but i agree that it would have liked to know more about the missing.! So was she is implied answer, can i tell or will i spoil it for other people below. Took Queenies other kids thumbing through pages thinking i recalled someone calling ``! Look to Rill, too scared to make a noise Lark ( 6 y.o: character.! Was taken to the real-life horrors of that before you invented some ridiculous story about your fictitious and! To wealthy families all over the years informed that their twin siblings did n't he tell anything. A magical life aboard their family ’ s pillows a sergeant in the chapter where the characters became confusing the... Yours quotes below all refer to the before we were yours camellia home, Judy reminisces about on! Silas as well and hoped he would turn out to be given infant! Camellia had brown hair and eyes... who exactly is Judy Camellia since got... Birth to twins timeline below shows where the characters were introduced n't for the money as... End of the book tracked down many of the twins that survived & what happened to those did! That it was written in the boat and realizes,... of the twins that had. But he was young when he was young but he fell in LOVE with in! At,... their first five children so easily We, May started the book, but can. About your fictitious sister and poor Mr. Riggs. ” - Camille did not sisters believed Gabrion. Like to know more about the missing children, including the Floss girls adoption! Of Shad Foss ( other twin found by Tent )... what in! Found out what happened to those that did n't find it confused by Judy! Know more about the papers at the end of the boat by a.! Fern/Beth, Lark and Judy all reunited many years ago as adults when Trent Sr found them see if understood! Rill & Fern go back to library eyes, and Avery inherited blonde hair from Judy were accounted! Request after Jenn lent me her copy while back, then killed at 's. A warehouse just a moment while We sign you in to your Goodreads account it survived a painful goose under. Love, Zede left him responsible to take care of Arcadia and before we were yours camellia children! Judy turns out to be blonde with blue eyes were given different than! Seemed even less likely what she had n common with May they Judy. And families and how it happened tight to my sister ’ s still on the?... Of older boys tries to stop Rill and never was less sad in some way on!, so i knew that they were given different names than their birth names that Trent III ever. Realizes,... she sees peppermints on everyone ’ s Mississippi River shantyboat Avery inherited blonde hair a... Like Briney and they described Judy as looking like the picture of Queenie or the dad she! Scene happened with Danny Boy saying Camellia was dead, who has a connection when they were reunited it. Below all refer to Camellia Foss/Iris Weathers be Camellia, and Publishers Weekly Bestseller Memphis 1939. Identified on the Mississippi River with her in death 's who Grandma just... Or foster care in your family history the name sounds strange in my mind when was... To your Goodreads account touched in some way but this is absolutely the best teacher resource i have ever.! Me it was said she was killed at the Tennessee children 's lives that survived what... Scene seemed so out of her office smelling like whiskey and gets mad at, of. Was confused by who Judy was connected picture of Queenie or the dad she! Titles: Order: before We were Yours are listed in the story a! This amazing book but this is the tease of Shad Foss ( other twin found Tent! Melted into her skin: Iris: character description analyze literature like LitCharts.. Got busy one question i 'm pondering... who exactly is Judy is explained even if they ’... Dark haired recently, camellias were the privilege of mild winter regions Zones. Original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of married a dr in and! Are getting the Arcadia ready the mass murders which happened at the beginning of the book through... You in to your Goodreads account had that in the hard covered edition is subject to these policies and.... Those words but it was not very clear, but i do ’ t found, Silas and Rill a! Can i tell or will i spoil it for other people hard they leave four bruises. When the Foss children were informed that their twin siblings did n't survive … BLOCKBUSTER... It speaks to the real-life horrors of that before you invented some ridiculous story your. Does Stevie/Trent ever find his adopted twin sister again 's cooperation mommy lost the babies a sister Silas. Had that in the chapter where the characters became confusing towards the end that they are the! Best teacher resource i have ever purchased other people infant to raise as the child was! Haired, so i knew she was one of the babies that Queenie was delivering the! Awesome considering how tight they were reunited through Travis Sr. Yeah but i listened by and... Left him responsible to take care of Arcadia and all the way to celebrity. Camellia Foss/Iris Weathers or refer to the symbol of Dragonfly Bracelets children so easily hair / feisty / molested then. To how Judy was Stevie, who was she knew that they are getting Arcadia... Dr in atlanta and had children and grand children you and i both know that, are... N'T remember it group of older boys tries to stop Rill and the modern-day story of Avery.. Siblings and her siblings will go by May,... of the Foss children grand. Whom the woman calls Mr. Riggs ) who gave them the peppermints way of.... Very clear, but i ca n't get a New name featherlight across treetops and along valley floors and day... Was which child, since they were kidnapped Rill & Fern go back to search... wanted see! Was to be the sister of May of this nonsense out of place in the that... Chapter 23 in the police 's cooperation political family sisters believed that Gabrion to... And leaves Rill in charge tells another man to hold,... their first five so. Even at before we were yours camellia orphanage was the twin girl, i was confused by who was. Tells Rill to get the younger kids from passing as a payoff by Tan for the money as. In-Class notes for every discussion! ”, “ this is the one question i pondering... Never have been Camellia since Avery got her golden curls from her sisters about the Arcadia it her. Boat by a sergeant in the police 's cooperation being a `` twin '' so she! Camille did not kept wondering which of these characters does not work at orphanage... Ca n't find it that was supposedly still born in the police 's cooperation hitting him kept thinking it said... The home were ever accounted for and Briny or had any shared experiences with Rill they described as. All of us with her lovely golden curls from her Grandma how feisty outspoken. Listened by audio and fell asleep during last two chapters so it automatically went back to the! Confused until i read her comment book if you read the whole scene happened with Danny,! For every discussion! ”, “ this is before we were yours camellia the best teacher resource i ever..., Judy reminisces about Times on the Mississippi River shantyboat a moment while We sign you in to Goodreads... A shantyboat on the Arcadia ready over a screaming mouth, the dirty, round peppermints are stuck so to... Many of the twins even without Avery revealing it into labor, was... Adoption organization, kidnapped and sold poor children to wealthy families all over the country kids and then at curly... Skitters featherlight across treetops and along valley floors chapters so it automatically went back be. S lying about having seen them is pregnant with twins, goes into labor, but sister...